Futures prop firms are seeing net margins compress as challenge prices drop while the costs of running accounts stay high or climb.
Manuel Sonnleithner, co-founder and CEO of TradersYard, told Finance Magnates that industry net margins have fallen from about 25-30% to 10-15%. Topstep’s $49 monthly 50K challenge plus a $149 activation fee once produced roughly $200 from a trader who passed in the first month. No-activation-fee models, popularised by firms like Lucid Trading, and aggressive promotions have pushed the effective cost of some 50K accounts down to $90-$100.
Platform and data costs have not followed the same path. Fees are often charged per user per month. Sonnleithner said paying $30 per user per month makes a $49 challenge difficult to sustain. Ruben Abitbol of RUBIK added that futures prop operating costs are generally higher than those of CFD props, pointing to platform fees around Tradovate and NinjaTrader plus CME market-data charges. Professional-tier data classification can take all-in data costs toward $2,000 a month.
Payout ratios add further pressure. Abitbol puts CFD prop payout ratios at 40-50% and futures at 70-80%. Firms have responded with lower payout caps, tighter structures, and earlier moves of consistently profitable traders onto live accounts.
Several 2026 closures fit the pattern. FundingTicks, the futures arm of FundingPips, wound down after rule changes that included a one-minute hold and lower splits. Alpha Futures closed its Premium Plan after losing NinjaTrader access. Rev One and FundedSeat cited limitations from large trading platforms as reasons they could not scale.
ProjectX ended third-party licensing, leaving the platform exclusive to Topstep. Several firms rebuilt on other stacks rather than close.
For traders the lower entry prices are real, but the margin squeeze usually shows up later in payout terms, consistency rules, or the speed at which profitable accounts are moved to live capital. Firms that control their own technology or price payout liability more carefully are better placed to keep the current model running.
Our Take: The race to the bottom on challenge fees is visible in the numbers. The firms that stay open will be those that stop treating cheaper entry as the only lever and start treating payout liability and platform costs as the real constraints. Traders should read the payout rules as carefully as the sale price.
Sources & Evidence
- 🟢 Primary source: Finance Magnates: The $49 Challenge Problem
- 🔵 Independent source: TradersYard CEO comments via Finance Magnates